Skip to content

Free tool · no sign-up

Reddit AI detector: does it read like AI?

Paste a Reddit comment, yours or one you found. It flags what readers take as AI or an ad: model vocabulary, the long dash, headings in a short reply, sales words, links and a missing disclosure.

Your reply

What readers and moderators see22 words

46

Reply score

Likely to be downvoted or removed as it stands.

  • Answers before it mentions anythingThe first sentence names Velka. Open with the answer to the question, then bring the product in.
  • Says who is writingYou work on Velka but the reply does not say so. Add a plain line like "I work on Velka, so I'm biased."
  • LinksOne link. Check the subreddit's rules; many remove comments with links.
  • Reads like an answer, not an adSales phrases: "best-in-class", "promo code", "check out". Say what it does in plain words instead.
  • Sounds written for this threadStock phrases that readers associate with canned replies: "great question".
  • Reads like a person wrote itNo signs readers associate with AI text.
  • Length22 words. A good length for a helpful comment.
  • Specific, from experienceIt has numbers or first-hand detail, which is what gets upvoted.
  • Calm toneCapitals or exclamation marks make a comment read like an advert.
  • Answers what was askedIt uses the question's own words: flat, feet.

Flagged in your reply

Great question! Check out Velka Glide 2, the best-in-class shoe for flat feet. Use promo code RUN20 at https://velka.example for a discount!!

How it works

Three steps.

The Reddit AI detector reads a comment and shows what makes it read like AI or an ad to Redditors: words models lean on, the long dash, headings and bold labels in a short reply, sentences of one length and no contractions, plus sales phrases, links, a missing disclosure and length. It scores the comment out of 100 and highlights the words. It runs in your browser and nothing is sent or saved. It shows signs readers react to; no tool can prove who wrote a text.

  1. Step 1

    Paste the comment

    The comment you are about to post, and the post it answers if you have it.

  2. Step 2

    Read the signs

    Up to ten checks, from AI phrasing to links and disclosure, each with what to change.

  3. Step 3

    Fix it, then post

    The flagged words light up in your text. Say it the way you would type it, then post.

By The Octosift team · Updated

01 · The checks

What reads like AI, and what reads like an ad

AI signs: words models lean on (delve, crucial, furthermore, a testament to), the long dash, headings and bold labels in a short reply, sentences all of one length, and no contractions in a long comment. Redditors spot these fast and downvote or report them.

Answer first: the opening sentence should help, not pitch. Say who is writing: if you work on the product you mention, the reply says so in plain words. Links: most communities remove comments with links, so none is safest.

Sales and stock phrases: words from adverts and the stock lines people associate with canned replies make readers stop trusting the rest. Length and detail: under about fifteen words reads as low effort; numbers and first-hand detail are what gets upvoted.

The same product, written two ways

Reads like an ad · score 46

Great question! Check out Velka Glide 2, the best-in-class shoe for flat feet. Use promo code RUN20 at https://velka.example for a discount!!

Reads like an answer · score 100

Flat-footed runner here. At 30 miles a week you want a firm medial post and a wide toe box, and swap the insoles around 150 miles since they die first. I work at Velka, so I'm biased, but our Glide 2 is $129 and built for this. The advice holds for any brand.

Sample accounts and posts, made up for this page.

02 · Disclosure

Why saying who you are matters

Redditors look at who is talking before they weigh what is said, and many communities' rules ask you to say when you are connected to what you recommend. US advertising rules on endorsements expect the same.

A reply that says "I work on this, so I'm biased" and then gives an honest answer is usually received far better than one that hides it and gets found out in the replies.

Example: a reply that says who is writing

r/running · 5h · u/Low_Tide_4417

Flat feet, 30 miles a week. Which shoes under $150 actually last?

37 comments

u/maya_velka· 3h

Flat-footed runner here. You want a firm medial post and a wide toe box. I work at Velka, so I'm biased, but our Glide 2 is built for exactly this ($129).

5ReplyShare

Said who is writing in the first lines

u/Low_Tide_4417OP· 2h

Appreciate you saying you work there. Ordering a pair tonight.

2ReplyShare

Sample accounts and posts, made up for this page.

03 · The limits

What it cannot check

It cannot prove who wrote a comment. People write with long dashes and models can write plainly; treat the result as how readers will see it, not as a verdict on a person. It also does not read the subreddit, so it cannot know that community's own rules, whether the thread is locked or archived, or the karma and account age a community asks for. Read the rules in the sidebar before posting.

Octosift reads each community's rules for you and checks every reply against them before it goes out, along with these checks.

What Octosift reads that this tool cannot

r/running · Community rules

  1. 1. No self-promotion in postsA comment that answers first is allowed here
  2. 2. Disclose any affiliationThe reply says who is writing
  3. 3. No links to shopsName the product; leave the link out
  4. 4. Accounts under 30 days are filteredA new account waits before it posts here

Sample accounts and posts, made up for this page.

Questions about the Reddit AI detector

Is the Reddit AI detector free?

Yes, with no sign-up and no limit. It runs in your browser and nothing is sent or saved.

Can you tell if a Reddit comment was written by AI?

Not for certain. You can see the signs readers react to: model vocabulary, the long dash, headings and lists in a short answer, sentences of one length and no contractions. The more of them a comment has, the more readers will assume AI wrote it.

Does Reddit ban AI-written comments?

Reddit's sitewide rules target spam and manipulation rather than AI text as such, but many subreddits ban AI-generated posts and comments in their own rules. Check the sidebar of the community you post in.

Can I mention my product in a Reddit comment?

Often, yes, if the community allows it, the comment answers the question first, and you say you work on it. Some subreddits forbid any self-promotion; their rules are in the sidebar.

Should I put a link in my Reddit reply?

Usually not. Many subreddits remove comments with links automatically, and readers can find a product by name. If a link is allowed and asked for, one is the limit.

Why does a reply get downvoted even if it is correct?

Because it reads like an advert: it leads with the product, uses sales words or does not engage with what was asked. The same facts, written as an answer, are often upvoted.

Does this tell me whether my comment will be removed?

No tool can promise that. Moderators and community rules decide. It flags the things that most often lead to removal so you can fix them first.

Keep going

Related

Find out who is asking for what you sell.

Paste your URL. Octosift reads your site, suggests the communities and buyer searches to watch, and starts bringing you threads.

7-day free trial. No card.