Reddit outreach that starts with an answer, not a pitch.
Cold DMs get ignored or reported. Octosift answers in the thread first, then writes to the few askers who fit, about the thing they asked.
The short answer
Octosift's Reddit outreach follows a public answer with a direct message, one person at a time. It first answers the question in the thread, where every reader and the AI assistants that read it can see. Then it decides whether the asker fits. If so, it writes one message about what they asked, with your offer. Many askers get no DM, and it never sends cold ones.
- Who gets a DM
- Askers you answered
- Pace
- One person at a time
- Who gets a DM
- Only people it answered
- Sends
- On full auto or after your yes
By The Octosift team · Updated
u/Low_Tide_4417
You answered them in r/running · 5 upvotes
Why this person
- Asked about flat feet
- Budget: $150
- Replied to your answer
01 · Why cold fails
A cold DM reads as spam, because it usually is.
A message from a stranger with a discount code and a link gets ignored, reported, and sometimes costs the account.
A message from the person who just answered your question is different. You asked, they helped, and now they are following up on the same thing.
Cold DM
Hi there! Love your posts. Velka makes the best running shoes on the market. Use code SAVE20 for 20% off everything, link in my profile!
Octosift
Hey, Maya from Velka here. I answered your flat feet question in r/running. You said $150 is the ceiling, so here is 20% off the Glide 2: code TIDE20. Happy to help with sizing either way.
Sample accounts and posts, made up for this page.
02 · In public first
The answer goes in the thread, where everyone sees it.
Every outreach starts with a real answer in public. The asker gets help, so do the next hundred readers, and the assistants that read the thread see your name next to useful advice.
Only then does it think about a message. If the public answer was all they needed, that is where it ends.
r/running · 5h · u/Low_Tide_4417
Flat feet, 30 miles a week. Which shoes under $150 actually last?
My last two pairs were dead by 250 miles. What are you all running in?
37 comments
u/maya_velka· 3hTop 1% Commenter
5ReplyShare
u/Low_Tide_4417OP· 2h
2ReplyShare
Sample accounts and posts, made up for this page.
03 · The message
Then one message, written for that person.
The message is built from what they wrote: the problem, the budget, how they replied. Low_Tide_4417 said $150 was the ceiling and was about to order, so the message says so and offers 20% off.
It comes from the same account that answered, so the conversation stays in one place, and their reply lands in your own Reddit inbox.
u/Low_Tide_4417· Chat
Hey, Maya from Velka here. I answered your flat feet question in r/running. You said $150 is the ceiling, so here is 20% off the Glide 2: code TIDE20. Happy to help with sizing either way.
oh nice, thank you! do they run narrow?
They run wide in the toe box. Go true to size.
Written from their post: flat feet, a $150 ceiling, a reply to your answer.Sample accounts and posts, made up for this page.
04 · Judgement
Most askers get no DM, and each skip has a reason.
A message is only worth sending when the person would want it. Often they would not: they asked to keep it public, they need something you do not sell, or they already bought.
Then the public answer is the whole job. Switch between four askers to see who got a message, and why the others did not.
r/RunningShoeGeeks · 6h · u/tempo_tess
Half marathon in 6 weeks, need a stable trainer under $140
411 comments
u/maya_velka· 5h
3ReplyShare
u/tempo_tessOP· 4h
1ReplyShare
r/beginnerrunning · 3h · u/wide_feet_wendy
Wide feet, first 10K. What should I try? Please answer here, no DMs
514 comments
u/maya_velka· 2h
4ReplyShare
r/trailrunning · 5h · u/fell_runner_88
Best grip for muddy fell races?
619 comments
u/maya_velka· 4h
5ReplyShare
r/running · 1d · u/slow_sunday_sam
Flat feet and 20 miles a week. Which shoes?
38 comments
u/maya_velka· 22h
4ReplyShare
u/slow_sunday_samOP· 3h
2ReplyShare
Sample accounts and posts, made up for this page.
05 · How it runs
From a public answer to a reply in your inbox.
One asker, start to finish. On full auto it all runs on its own. On ask me first, every message waits for your yes, and you can edit it before it goes.
- In the threadIt answers the question in publicHelp first, then who is writing
- ThenIt reads the askerTheir post, their replies, any budget
- DecisionDM or no DMMost end here, with the reason
- If they fitIt writes one messageAbout what they asked, with your offer
- SentOn full auto, or after your yesFrom the account that answered
- ReplyThey write back to youIn your own Reddit inbox
Sample accounts and posts, made up for this page.
Compared
Reddit DMs, three ways
What happens to the same asker with each approach.
| What is compared | Cold DM tools | By hand | Octosift |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who gets a message | Lists of strangers | Whoever you remember | Askers you answered in public |
| A public answer comes first | No | Sometimes | Yes |
| Written for one person | Template with a name | Yes | Yes |
| Decides not to send | No | Your call | Often, with the reason |
| Offer matched to what they asked | Same code for all | If you have time | Yes |
| Respects "no DMs, please" | No | Yes | Yes |
| Volume | In bulk | A few, when you can | One person at a time |
| You read it before it goes | No | Yes | Your choice |
Questions
Reddit outreach, asked and answered.
Is it OK to DM people on Reddit about your product?
Cold promotional DMs are widely treated as spam on Reddit, and many communities ban them. A short follow-up to someone whose question you just answered, about that question, is different. It is the only kind Octosift sends.
Does it send Reddit DMs automatically?
If you want it to. On full auto it follows up by itself. On ask me first, every message waits for your yes, and you can edit it.
Who does it message?
Only people whose question it answered in public and who fit what you sell. It never messages strangers from a list, and it never sends the same message to many people.
Why did it not message someone it answered?
Every skip has a reason you can read: they asked for no DMs, they need something you do not sell, they already bought, or the public answer was all they needed.
Can the message include a discount code?
Yes. Tell it what you can offer, such as a code, a trial or a call, and it uses it where it suits the person, like the 20% code for a buyer with a $150 budget.
Which account sends the messages?
The same Reddit account that answered in the thread, so the conversation stays in one place and replies land in your own Reddit inbox.
How many DMs does it send a day?
There is no quota to fill. It writes one message at a time, only after a public answer and only when the asker fits. Most people it answers never get one.
Where to go next
It works with the rest.

Find out who is asking for what you sell.
Paste your URL. Octosift reads your site, suggests the communities and buyer searches to watch, and starts bringing you threads.

